Share
|
This past spring, Dr. Ila Singh at the
University of Utah conducted one of three recent studies testing HIV
antiretrovirals against XMRV in vitro
(in the test tube). Singh
discovered that two drugs—tenofovir and raltegravir—killed the XMRV retrovirus,
and corroborated an earlier study by the Mayo Clinic
that concluded that AZT is also effective against XMRV. In addition, Singh found any two
combinations of these three drugs were synergistic. She didn’t test all three drugs together, so it’s not known
if a triple cocktail would be even more effective. It’s also possible that the triple cocktail could be less effective than a two-drug combo.
Likewise, a June 2010 study by the National Cancer Institute
also found that AZT, tenofovir and raltegravir inhibit XMRV in vitro. Here’s
a capsule view of the three drugs:
Nucleoside
Analogue Reverse Transcriptase Inhibitors
Zidovudine (brand name AZT). FDA-approved in 1987, AZT was the first drug used to treat
HIV/AIDS, though it was developed in the 1960s as a cancer drug. In 1974, German scientist Max Planck
discovered that AZT was active against a mouse retrovirus called Friend murine
leukemia virus, a close cousin of XMRV.
In HIV, AZT works by stopping the enzyme reverse transcriptase
from converting the retrovirus’s RNA into DNA, which is then integrated into
the genetic material of the host’s cells. Normally DNA transcribes (converts)
RNA. Reverse transcription is the
reverse: RNA transcribes DNA. Nucleoside
analogue reserve transcriptase inhibitors are often abbreviated NRTIs.
Common side effects of AZT
include: nausea, loss of appetite, headache, tiredness, vomiting,
constipation, asthenia (weakness).
Less common side effects: anemia, bone-marrow suppression,
bruising, muscle pain and myopathy (muscle weakness), mitochondrial toxicity
and lactic acidosis, body-fat redistribution, elevated liver enzymes and liver
damage, a bluish discoloration of fingernails and toenails, and allergic
reactions. Nausea is the most
common side effect from AZT and can be minimized by taking the drug with
food. However, high-fat meals tend
to exacerbate the nausea.
Nucleotide
Analogue Reverse Transcriptase Inhibitors
Tenofovir (brand name Viread). Nucleoside analogs are converted into nucleotide analogs by the body. If you take nucleotide analog
reverse transcriptase inhibitors (often abbreviated NtRTIs), you bypass that
step. FDA-approved in 2008,
Tenofovir, like AZT, blocks the retroviral attack on the host’s healthy cells
by preventing the reverse transcriptase enzyme from doing its job of transcribing single-stranded viral RNA
into double-stranded viral DNA.
Common side effects of tenofovir
include: diarrhea, headache, pain,
depression, rash, asthenia (weakness), nausea. Less common side effects: vomiting,
gas, loss of appetite, weight loss, insomnia, dizziness, sweating, muscle pain
and myopathy (muscle weakness), mitochondrial toxicity and lactic acidosis,
kidney and liver damage, Fanconi
syndrome, exacerbation of hepatitis, decrease in bone density, elevated
blood sugar, fast or irregular heartbeat, and allergic reactions. Kidney toxicity can occur within the
first few months of taking Tenofovir, so kidney function must be
monitored. Dehydration contributes
to kidney toxicity and can be minimized by drinking more water.
Integrase
Inhibitors
Raltegravir (brand name Isentress): FDA-Approval in 2007, it’s the first and only approved
integrase inhibitor, though others are in the pipeline. Integrase inhibitors block a later
phase of retroviral integration than NtRTIs or NRTIs do. Raltegravir prevents the enzyme called integrase
from inserting double-stranded viral DNA into the host cells’
DNA.
Common side effects of
raltegravir include: rash, headache,
nausea, asthenia (weakness) and fatigue.
Less common side effects: gastritis, abdominal pain, insomnia,
dizziness, fever, anemia, diarrhea, insomnia, rash, kidney damage, kidney
failure, high blood sugar, depression, and allergic reactions.
With HIV patients, one drug is
started and a second drug in added one to two weeks later, and a third drug is
added one to two weeks after that.
Dr. Ila Singh discussing XMRV and the HIV drugs being tested in animals inoculated with XMRV:
Dr. Ila Singh discussing XMRV and the HIV drugs being tested in animals inoculated with XMRV:
Video Courtesy of KSL.com
This post should not be
construed as medical advice. Nor
is this post an endorsement of the use of antiretrovirals for ME/CFS patients
and an XMRV diagnosis. I am a
science writer, not a physician or a researcher. Consult your health-care professional before beginning any
treatment plan.
Coming up: Drugs that may help clear XMRV reservoirs. Plus an interview with the CDC's Dr. Steve Monroe, director of the CDC’s division of High Consequence Pathogens and Pathology.
This
article is copyright CFS
Central
2010. All Rights Reserved. You may quote up to 150 words
from this article as long as you indicate in the body of your post (as
opposed
to a footnote or an endnote) that the excerpt is by Mindy Kitei for CFS
Central. You may not reprint more than 150 words from this article on
blogs, forums, websites or any other online or print venue. Instead,
refer readers to this blog to
read the article.
On April 1, 2010, Dr. Singh did an interview with a local Utah television station (http://www.ksl.com/index.php?nid=148&sid=10239583&s_cid=E0002), discussing the results of her PLoS One article on Raltegravir: http://www.plosone.org/article/info:doi%2F10.1371%2Fjournal.pone.0009948.
ReplyDeleteIn the TV interview, Dr. Singh discusses studies already underway with Colorado State Univ. designed to assess the effectiveness of ARV therapy targeting XMRV in lab animals.
Thanks, CBS. I just embedded the Dr. Singh interview in the post.
ReplyDeleteIt's great to have you Mindy. Your articles makes the waiting for progress a little less unbearable. The lack of news can be mindnumbing sometimes. THANK YOU!
ReplyDeleteThank you for another excellent article. It is so good to have the information on these three drugs condensed in one place.
ReplyDelete--Patricia Carter
www.mecfsforums.com
Thanks, Mindy. People keep talking about the nasty side-effects of antiretrovirals, but aside from the potential for kidney and/or liver damage, the side-effects sound pretty much like what ME/CFS patients live with everyday anyway. I wonder if the people warning about how bad the side-effects are to live with have any idea what living with ME/CFS is like.
ReplyDeleteInteresting clip of Dr Singh. And a good reminder of how much needs to happen before those drugs are ready for XMRV patients (assuming the evidence ends up showing that XMRV causes disease). We've got a long wait ahead of us.
I agree,I am an FM patient and acknowledge that these symptoms are indeed what we live with daily,My concern though,Would taking these meds not exacerbate the the already nasty symptoms of FM.
ReplyDeleteWould one need to take these drugs indefinitely?
ReplyDeleteI have a mild case of CFS, so from where I stand, the side effects look pretty bad. If I could take it for a while and kill the retrovirus, it would be worth it. If I had to take it forever, not a good deal for me.
unfortunately, you would have to take the drugs forever...unless they come up with a way to eradicate retrovirus from all latent cells, which is a long way off i think.
ReplyDeletemindy....great article. i hadn't heard about research to get at the XMRV reservoirs yet! is this brand new info?
thank you
-s
Anonymous, The reservoir stuff is theoretical at present, but interesting. There's been some exploration to clearing the HIV reservoirs, but actual therapies are still years away. If you could completely clear the retroviral reservoirs, theoretically you could conceivably be cured of HIV, discontinue therapy and remain healthy.
ReplyDeleteThis info may seem off the wall to many of you but here goes: I have fibromyalgia/CFS. A 50 year old cousin was originally rx'd with Parkinsons but two years later told he has Lyme. He landscapes wild animal parks, zoos, etc. Lyme makes a lot of sense. I researched and researched and discovered Carnivora.com. If you Google Carnivora HIV you will see studies whereby it successfully treated HIV. Same with Lyme. Carnivora is based on the Venus Fly Trap plant. After three months my cousin is feeling well enough to go back to work. After this info re MFRV reached me I put myself on Carnivora. Too soon to tell but I am hopeful. Think it sure beats HIV cocktails. Personal opinion of course.
ReplyDeleteBarbara Lochner
This is very great thing you have shared with us. Now I found enough resources by your tips about this issue, Thank you.
ReplyDelete